With 19 years in the recruitment industry, I’ve seen my fair share of interview techniques. My opinion (for what it’s worth) – if you believe the goal is to:
🔨 Immediately exert your position of power
🧨 See how long it takes to make them “crack”
🙄 Keep them guessing, show no emotion. Don’t even think about a smile.
You should probably assign interviews to someone else within the organisation.
Unless you’re recruiting for the special forces, consider a human-to-human interaction, encourage feelings of comfort, allow the walls to drop and personalities to poke through. You’ll discover whether someone will actually thrive in your culture – not just survive your interview process.
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: in a market where 76% of UK employers are struggling to fill roles, you simply cannot afford to intimidate talent away. Yet that’s precisely what’s happening in boardrooms and meeting rooms across the country, where outdated interview techniques rooted in power dynamics are pushing candidates towards your competitors – or out of the market entirely.
The cost of getting this wrong? Try £132,000 for a single mid-manager bad hire. Factor in damaged employer brands, rejected offers, and candidates who share their negative experiences with everyone they know, and you’ve got a recruitment crisis that’s entirely self-inflicted.
It’s time we had an honest conversation about what interviews are actually supposed to achieve – and why treating them like interrogations is one of the most expensive mistakes you can make.
The Interview Experience Crisis in UK Hiring
Let’s start with what candidates are actually experiencing when they walk into your interview rooms. The data paints a rather bleak picture:
- 93% of people have experienced job interview-related anxiety
- 46% of candidates believe their time is not respected by employers during interviews
- 37% feel intimidated when there are two or more interviewers present
- 64% state that asking “inappropriate questions” is the biggest mistake an interviewer can make
- Over 25% of candidates reported experiencing bias during interviews
Read those statistics again. Nearly half of candidates feel their time isn’t valued. More than a third are intimidated by panel interviews. These aren’t candidates being overly sensitive – these are warning signs that something is fundamentally broken in how we approach assessment.
And here’s where it gets expensive: 83% of candidates say a negative interview experience can cause them to reject a role or company they once liked. Think about that. You’ve invested in employer branding, advertised the role, screened CVs, coordinated diaries – and then your interview process undoes all of that work in a single hour.
The reputational damage extends far beyond the individual candidate:
- 72% of candidates who have a bad experience will tell friends, colleagues and family about it
- 54% of candidates have walked away from a job due to poor communication
- 49% of job seekers have turned down an offer because of a bad experience during the hiring process
In an era where every interaction is one Glassdoor review away from public scrutiny, this matters more than ever. 60% of job seekers say they would not apply for a job at a company with a 1-star Glassdoor rating, and three in five UK candidates would be discouraged from applying to a company if their Glassdoor account showed negative interview reviews.
Perhaps most damaging: a 1-star improvement in a company’s Glassdoor rating raises the odds that a typical candidate will apply by 25%. Your interview technique isn’t just affecting individual hires – it’s shaping your entire talent pipeline for years to come.
The irony? We’re doing this to ourselves in a market where talent is already scarce. The UK faces an 18-year high in recruitment difficulties, with Brexit resulting in the loss of over 300,000 workers and 37% of UK employers battling “hard to fill” vacancies. One-third of businesses have been unable to grow due to labour shortages.
When the pool is already shallow, can you really afford to be scaring the fish away?
The True Cost of Getting It Wrong
Bad hires aren’t cheap, and rushed or flawed interview processes are a significant contributor to making the wrong call. The numbers are sobering:
- The true cost of a bad hire in the UK ranges from 1.5 to 4 times the employee’s annual salary
- A poor hire at mid-manager level with a salary of £42,000 can cost a business more than £132,000
- 85% of UK organisations admit their organisation has made a bad hire
- 95% of UK businesses admit to making at least one bad hiring decision every year
- Bad hires reduce team productivity by 72%
Here’s what particularly interests me: one in three businesses made a bad hire due to rushing to fill positions. But rushing who through what process?
When I see companies conducting aggressive, power-based interviews – the kind designed to see how quickly someone will “crack” – I have to ask: what are you actually assessing? Compliance under pressure? The ability to maintain composure whilst being deliberately unsettled?
Unless that’s literally the job description, you’re testing for the wrong things. And worse, you’re creating an environment where candidates give you rehearsed, guarded answers rather than authentic insights into who they are and how they think.
The connection between interview approach and hiring outcomes is clear. When candidates feel intimidated, disrespected, or subjected to inappropriate questioning, they’re either going to withdraw (taking their talent elsewhere) or push through whilst hiding their true selves. Neither scenario helps you assess cultural fit or long-term potential.
With the average cost per hire in the UK sitting at £6,125, every failed hire is a significant investment loss. But the real cost isn’t just financial – it’s the opportunity cost of not having the right person in the role, the impact on team morale, the drain on management time, and the damage to your employer brand.
Why the ‘Crack Them’ Approach Fails
Let’s address the elephant in the room: stress interviews and power-play tactics.
Some hiring managers swear by them. They argue that pressure-testing candidates reveals how they’ll perform under stress, that keeping them off-balance prevents rehearsed answers, that maintaining emotional distance creates professional boundaries.
The research tells a different story.
Whilst stress interviews exist ostensibly to test resilience, a poorly conducted stress interview can lead to frustration, confusion, or negative perceptions of the company, with some candidates feeling unfairly treated or humiliated, losing interest in the role, and sharing negative interview experiences that impact the company’s employer brand.
Here’s the fundamental problem with the “crack them” approach: it assumes that compliance under artificial pressure equals capability under real-world job pressure. It doesn’t.
When you deliberately create an adversarial environment, you’re testing someone’s ability to manage their anxiety in an unusual social situation – not their ability to do the actual job. You’re assessing their tolerance for being treated poorly, not their potential to contribute meaningfully to your organisation.
Consider what happens psychologically when a candidate walks into an interview and encounters:
- Hostile or emotionless interviewers who refuse to smile or create any rapport
- Multiple panel members creating an inherently intimidating dynamic (remember, 37% already feel uncomfortable with two or more interviewers)
- Deliberately ambiguous or “gotcha” questions designed to catch them out
- Power displays that emphasise the company’s position and the candidate’s lack of leverage
The walls go up. The authentic personality disappears. You get the interview persona – the carefully managed, defensively positioned version of the candidate who’s now focused on surviving the interaction rather than genuinely engaging with it.
Research has found that conversational job interviews using well-designed questioning sequences are incredibly effective in getting candidates to move past rehearsed answers and open up to reveal who they really are. The path to authenticity isn’t through intimidation – it’s through genuine dialogue.
Unless you’re recruiting for the special forces, where the ability to maintain composure under extreme duress is literally a job requirement, ask yourself: what are you actually achieving with these techniques? And at what cost?
The Case for Human-Centred Interviewing
Here’s what we know from research about effective interview approaches:
Conversational interviewing helps candidates feel more relaxed and give more honest answers, shows a more authentic side of how employers interact with employees, and acknowledges that the employment decision is a two-way street.
This isn’t about lowering standards or making interviews “easy.” It’s about creating an environment where both parties can assess fit accurately. Because here’s the truth that some hiring managers seem to forget: candidates are interviewing you too.
The data on positive experiences is compelling:
- 87% say a positive interview experience can attract them to a role or company they once doubted
- 75% of employees say that having a positive candidate experience influenced their decision to take a job
- In 2024, candidates’ willingness to refer others increased dramatically when they rated their interview fairness with 4- and 5-star ratings
These aren’t soft metrics. In candidate-short markets like financial planning, Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central, insurance loss adjusting, or insolvency (where, frankly, there’s almost no movement at all), every interaction with potential talent matters. You cannot afford to have three-quarters of your offer recipients choosing competitors because your interview process put them off.
Research has found that companies using structured interviews (which can include conversational elements) are more likely to improve candidate experiences, efficiency, and quality of hire. Structure doesn’t mean sterile. You can have rigorous, well-designed questioning sequences that still feel human.
At Burton Recruitment, we see this play out constantly across our specialist markets. When our recruitment partners – each with an average of eight years’ experience in their respective fields – conduct candidate interviews, the goal isn’t to test how long someone can withstand discomfort. It’s to understand whether this move genuinely coincides with their preferences and requirements, and whether they’ll thrive in the client’s culture.
Our candidates frequently praise the depth of our service precisely because we treat them as whole people, not just CVs to be stress-tested. We’re communicative, thorough, and yes – we create an environment where personalities can emerge. Because that’s how you assess cultural fit. Not by seeing who can best maintain a poker face whilst being deliberately unsettled.
The conversational approach achieves what power-play tactics cannot:
- It surfaces authentic responses rather than rehearsed deflections
- It allows you to assess emotional intelligence and communication style in a realistic context
- It demonstrates your company culture in real-time (if you’re cold and adversarial in interviews, candidates assume that’s how you operate generally)
- It creates space for candidates to ask meaningful questions and assess their own fit
- It respects the two-way nature of the employment decision
When the walls drop and personalities poke through – that’s when you learn whether someone will actually thrive in your organisation. Not just whether they can survive your interview process.
What Good Actually Looks Like
So what does human-centred interviewing look like in practice? It’s not about abandoning rigour or assessment standards. It’s about being intentional with your approach.
Interviews should encourage a conversational tone rather than making the interview feel like an interrogation, as this approach puts candidates at ease and fosters more authentic dialogue.
Here are the practical elements:
Create Genuine Comfort
This doesn’t mean being unprofessional or overly casual. It means:
- Greeting candidates warmly and helping them settle before diving into questions
- Explaining the interview structure so they know what to expect
- Showing emotion (yes, you’re allowed to smile)
- Acknowledging that interviews are inherently a bit strange and artificial
- Building rapport before moving into assessment territory
Remember, 46% of candidates feel their time isn’t respected in interviews. Simple gestures – starting on time, explaining delays, being present and engaged – signal respect.
Use Well-Designed Questioning Sequences
Conversational doesn’t mean unstructured. Design your questions to:
- Build progressively from easier to more complex topics
- Encourage storytelling rather than yes/no responses
- Follow up on interesting threads rather than rigidly sticking to a script
- Allow for natural dialogue whilst ensuring you cover key competencies
- Use behavioural questions that invite candidates to share real examples
The goal is to get past rehearsed answers. That happens through genuine curiosity and follow-up questions, not through surprise attacks.
Balance Assessment with Respect
You can thoroughly assess someone’s capabilities whilst still treating them like a human being. This means:
- Being transparent about next steps and timelines
- Providing an opportunity for candidates to ask questions (and actually engaging with those questions)
- Acknowledging the effort they’ve put into preparing
- Offering feedback when possible, even to unsuccessful candidates
- Recognising that every candidate could be a future customer, partner, or referral source
Consider Your Panel Dynamics
If 37% of candidates feel intimidated by panel interviews, think carefully about your set-up:
- Do you need three people in the room, or would two suffice?
- Have you briefed your panel on creating a welcoming dynamic?
- Are you varying the emotional tone (having at least one person who maintains warmth and encouragement)?
- Have you planned who asks what, so it doesn’t feel like an onslaught?
Remember: Your Interview Is Your Employer Brand
Every interviewer is an extension of your company culture. If you’re dismissive, cold, or power-focused in interviews, candidates will assume that’s your culture. And in a market where 50% of job seekers say they wouldn’t work for a company with a bad reputation, even for a pay raise, you’re actively sabotaging your talent acquisition efforts.
The Competitive Advantage of Treating Candidates Like Humans
Let’s bring this back to the reality of UK hiring in 2025.
You’re operating in markets where talent is scarce. Financial planning is struggling with a lack of fresh talent and ageing demographics. Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central is a candidate shortage market with companies fighting over the same people. Insurance loss adjusters are hard to find and rarely move. Insolvency? The talent pool has effectively dried up.
In this environment, 37% of UK employers have “hard to fill” vacancies and one-third of businesses have been unable to grow due to labour shortages. Every candidate interaction is precious. Every offer rejection is costly.
You cannot afford to have 49% of job seekers turning down offers because of bad process experiences. You cannot afford to have 83% of candidates rejecting roles due to negative interview experiences. You cannot afford to have 72% of people telling their networks about poor treatment.
Your interview process should be your competitive advantage, not your bottleneck.
When competitors are still operating with 1990s power-play tactics, treating interviews like interrogations and candidates like supplicants, you have an opportunity. Create a human-centred process that:
- Respects candidates’ time and expertise
- Assesses rigorously whilst maintaining dignity
- Surfaces authentic personalities and cultural fit
- Demonstrates your actual working culture
- Leaves every candidate – successful or not – with a positive impression of your organisation
This isn’t about being “soft” or lowering standards. 66% of companies experienced negative effects on their business due to a bad hire, including reduced productivity and increased training costs. You still need to get the hire right. You just need to recognise that intimidation tactics don’t improve assessment accuracy – they undermine it.
The question I’d challenge you to ask: audit your interview approach honestly. Are you assessing capabilities and cultural fit, or are you simply testing who can best tolerate being treated poorly? Are you discovering whether candidates will thrive in your culture, or just whether they can survive your interview process?
After 19 years in this industry, I can tell you with absolute certainty: the best hires come from the best conversations. The ones where walls drop, personalities emerge, and both parties get genuine insights into whether this could be a successful long-term match.
The ones where you treat people like humans, not like problems to be cracked.
Ready to Rethink Your Approach?
At Burton Recruitment, we’ve spent years perfecting the art of matching hard-to-reach talent with the companies that need them. Across financial planning, insurance, Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central, insolvency, and executive search, our specialist consultants understand that assessment doesn’t require intimidation.
Whether you’re struggling to attract talent in candidate-short markets, concerned about the cost of bad hires, or simply questioning whether your current interview process is serving you well, we’d welcome a conversation.
Our approach is built on integrity, expert knowledge, and confidentiality. We understand culture because we take the time to understand your organisation as a whole – not just the job description. And we assess candidates thoroughly whilst maintaining the kind of human-centred approach that actually surfaces who people are.
Get in touch for a consultation on improving your hiring outcomes. Because in markets this competitive, your interview process could be the difference between securing top talent and watching them accept offers elsewhere.


